Mormon Stories Podcast Claims “Church Courts Just for “Weeding Out Non-Followers”?

Claim from Episode 2027: Todd McCormick stated, “I think the whole point of this [church court system] is just to weed out people who don’t follow the prophet.”

The Real Purpose of Disciplinary Councils

This characterization is not only cynical—it’s incorrect. The Church’s membership councils (formerly called “disciplinary councils”) serve to help individuals repent, protect others from harm, and maintain the integrity of the gospel.

These decisions aren’t made lightly. They require love, inspiration, and discernment. Disagreeing with the prophet isn’t grounds for expulsion—open rebellion against Church teachings while misleading others is a different matter entirely.

The Guidelines Say Otherwise

• General Handbook Section 32.6.3 outlines when councils are necessary.
• President Oaks’ talk “Truth and the Plan” offers context for how truth and love work in spiritual governance.

Bottom line? If Church councils were about “weeding out,” we’d all be toast. Thank heavens for a gospel of patience and progress.